JTA: The Global News Service of the Jewish People

Bagel brawl: N.Y. vs. Montreal

Jennifer 8. Lee blogs on the question of whether Montreal boasts better bagels than ... New York!?!

Are Montreal bagels really better than New York bagels?

City Room had been hearing about these legendary Montreal bagels from our readers. They were sweeter and less bloated. Since they were baked in a wood-burning oven, they had crisper crusts.

So we decided to pay a visit to Montreal’s bagel world to understand the rival to our native bagels. Montreal, which saw an influx of Jewish immigrants both before and after World War II, had become one of the main world centers of distinctive Jewish cuisine. Two Montreal bakeries stand out above all the others: Fairmount Bagel and St.-Viateur’s Bagel, both in the Mile End neighborhood.

What we found: Montreal bagel makers had no problem trash-talking New York bagels...

Read the full story.

  • Share Share

Comments RSS Feed Reader Comments

12/02/09 08:09 PM

No comparison as an x Montrealer i can tell you that the bagels in Montreal are the best in N America in Israel are some good bagels in Askelon.
Amnon

12/03/09 09:09 AM

As an ex NYer and former resident of the border region near Montreal I can tell Amnon that he has this backwards.  Montreal bagels are too hard and too sweet, they are suitable only for feeding birds.

Leave a Comment

To leave a comment, you must first be logged in to JTA. If you are not registered, please click here.

Already a JTA member?

I forgot my password

Need to know? Get JTA's free e-newsletters!