JTA: The Global News Service of the Jewish People

Saperstein: O’Reilly owes Pelosi an apology

By Eric Fingerhut · October 3, 2008

Bill O'Reilly compared the body language of Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi to Adolf Hitler on his show earlier this week, and Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism Rabbi David Saperstein thinks the Fox News host ought to apologize for such a "preposterous and insulting" analogy. Here's his letter to "O'Reilly Factor" executive producers David Tabacoff and Amy Sohnen:

I write in response to commentator Bill O'Reilly's recent statement comparing Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi's presentation style and body language to that of Nazi dictator Adolph Hitler's.

Although O'Reilly cynically claimed, "I'm not making any comparisons here," his decision to equate Speaker Pelosi's public speaking style with the very personification of evil in our time is, by definition, a comparison – a particularly preposterous and insulting one, at that. Nothing in her manner or substance – nothing – resembled the hate-filled rants Hitler was so known for. Such an inappropriate, ill-conceived analogy represents a smear campaign designed to further divide an already politically polarized American public.

This is not the first time Mr. O'Reilly has used his television show as an outlet for drawing supposed parallels between Nazi Germany and those current-day politicians and media outlets with whom he disagrees. In the past he has accused The Huffington Post of employing "the exact same tactics that the Nazis used … to demonize certain groups of people" and later called former Vice President Al Gore an "evil enabler" for speaking at a convention that he inexplicably compared to gatherings held by both the Ku Klux Klan and the Nazi Party.

Such repeated comparisons by Mr. O'Reilly display blatant insensitivity to the far-reaching effects of the evil perpetrated by Hitler and the Nazis. In repeatedly comparing respected political figures with Hitler and Nazis, he trivializes the distinctive evil that Hitler represents.

Mr. O'Reilly owes Speaker Pelosi an apology. I urge that you insist it be given as a requirement of the journalistic standards of the network and, should he refuse, that you act accordingly.

10 Comments | Share This | Uncategorized |

Mason takes on Silverman

By Ben Harris · October 3, 2008

Fresh on the heels of Sarah Silverman telling the world she's going to blame the Jews if Barack Obama loses comes this new vid from Jackie Mason, courtesy of the Republican Jewish Coalition. Mason doesn't like the yenta Silverman's suggestion that if you don't vote for Obama it's because you're a racist.

5 Comments | Share This | Presidential Race |

Political tidbits: Palin knocked for Israel answer, Biden criticized for Lebanon claim

By Eric Fingerhut · October 3, 2008

• Sarah Palin's answer on Israel last night sounded like she was "randomly spewing every talking point she'd ever uploaded on Israel," writes Noam Scheiber in The New Republic.
• Michael Totten, in Commentary, wonders what Joe Biden was talking about when he claimed that the U.S. "kicked Hezbollah out of Lebanon."
• Rick Siegel, in the Huffington Post, said he only heard one "snort" all night from Biden – when Palin said she was "so encouraged to know we both love Israel."
• Holocaust survivor Rachel Patron, writing in the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, says Jewish voters need more from the candidates than just promises of preventing a "second Holocaust."
• Shmuel Rosner, in Commentary, also doesn't like the analogy, calling it "more frightening than reassuring."
• Joe Lieberman predicts McCain will hit 40 percent of the Jewish vote, according to the Philadelphia Jewish Exponent.
• The National Journal puts the National Jewish Democratic Council and Republican Jewish Coalition in its "Ad Spotlight."
• NJDC executive director Ira Forman, in the Huffington Post, criticizes the RJC's "guilt by association" ads and quotes Joseph Welch's famous line to Joe McCarthy, "Have you no sense of decency, sir?"

9 Comments | Share This | ads, Barack Obama, debates, Israel, Jerusalem, Joe Biden, Joe Lieberman, John McCain, Presidential Race, Sarah Palin, Tidbits |